Very Odd Email
I've just recieved the weirdest email:
Strange, huh? The only place I can think of that they could have harvested my email address from (I'm assuming this was a bulk email) is from a PRA, since I only used that address when I was in Maynooth. Also they're calling me Dr. Fitzsimons, which indicates it was probably taken from the paper. Anyone else been getting emails like this? Have they sent the same email to everyone whos published in an aps journal, or any journal for that matter?
DEAR DR. FITZSIMONS,
It is my pleasure to inform you that you are being considered for inclusion in
the upcoming 2007 (24th) Edition of WHO'S WHO IN THE WORLD(R), which is
scheduled for publication in November 2006.
Distributed globally, Marquis' WHO'S WHO IN THE WORLD is relied upon by business
leaders, journalists, academics, and other professionals for its accuracy and
currency of information. Additionally, it is found in the collections of many
of the world's leading libraries and corporations.
As the Marquis Who's Who editors begin assembling the 24th Edition of this
historic publication, the original WHO'S WHO IN THE WORLD continues to be
recognized internationally as the premier biographical data source of notable
living individuals from every significant field of endeavor.
To be considered for inclusion as a biographee in this prestigious publication,
you need only provide the requested information by completing the Biographical
Data Form at:
...cropped...Through this
link you will also find more information about the edition of WHO'S WHO IN THE
WORLD currently in print.
To be sure you are considered, please submit your biography by 5/18/06.
The information you provide will be evaluated according to the selection
standards Marquis Who's Who has developed over 100 years as the world's premier
biographical publisher. If your data passes our initial screening, we will
prepare your biography in Marquis Who's Who format and send you a
pre-publication proof for your verification and approval.
Inclusion in WHO'S WHO IN THE WORLD offers... -More than just a personal
achievement-being honored in a Marquis Who's Who publication offers prospective
business contacts an authoritative, full representation of your credentials and
accomplishments. -A historical archive of your achievements, recorded for
generations to refer to time and again. -Exclusive offers that are available
only to members of the Marquis Who's Who family.
I congratulate you on the achievements that have brought your name to the
attention of our editorial committee. We look forward to hearing from you.
Sincerely,
Robert Docherty
Editorial Director
UPDATE
I've just been sent a link to this Forbes article (thanks Donald!) about Who's Who. It would seem that the books do in fact exist, but that its basically a vanity publication with virtually no entry barrier and one which sells it's biographee's (is this a real word?) addresses to direct mail companies. Here are a few choice wuotes from the article:
A call to the company's business office proves more fruitful. Who's Who, it turns out, does a pretty good business renting the names and addresses of its 250,000 Honored Biographees to direct mail marketers. People who are listed in Who's Who, Marquis assures marketers in its promotional literature, "are interested in many types of offers," including pitches for new credit cards, magazine subscriptions, catalogues, association memberships and "fundraising opportunities." The entire database can be rented on computer tape for about $22,000. Or, the woman on the phone says, the list can be broken down by profession, sex, political affiliation or religion. There are 17,600 self-identified Catholics in Who's Who, she explains by way of example, and 5,300 Jews.(Emphasis mine)
Donald Ray Grubbs of Portland, Texas, is proof that persistence pays off. From 1973 to 1986, Donald Ray worked as a pipe fitter and welder for the Pipefitters Local 195 in Beaumont. Now an employee of Longview Inspection, a company that assesses the structural integrity of industrial sites, Grubbs has been appearing in various Who's Who publications for a decade or so.I think that this last one really explains the invitation to be included:
Or say hello to Stephen Geiman, who teaches gym at Wilson Memorial High School in Fishersville, Virginia. From 1970 to 1972, Geiman, a graduate of the physical education program at Appalachian State University, was the school's driver's ed instructor. Or David Dolsen, an undertaker in Denver. Or Amy Fung, an accountant from Staten Island. And let's not forget Mary Morgan, a 55-year-old social worker in Elizabethtown, Kentucky.


11 Comments:
I've been getting those for years. Never bothered to look into it, but it certainly looks like phishing for personal information to be used or sold for ID theft purposes (e.g. signing off on massive orders for expensive equipment). Unless you are prepared to invest the time to check it very thoroughly and make absolutely sure it's legit, just stay away from it.
Yes, that's what I was thinking. To many places use your date of birth or mothers maiden name as security. Of course, unless someone thinks my mothers maiden name is "Don't give out this password! Ever!", I don't think I'm at to much risk. They have at least gone to the trouble of putting up a shiny(ish) site. I'm just interested to know where they've harvested the email address from. As it is, it gets no spam.
I've gotten one of those emails too. As far as I can tell it is not phishing. Those who's who books actually exist and can be be found in any university library. The editorial board is made up of well known scientists. I think the "scam" aspect is just that if they put you into the book, they will then send you advertisements trying to convince you to buy a copy.
Yes, aps journals. I got an e-mail too. The strange thing is, last year I got one for "Who's who in science and engineering", which seemed at least to make a little bit of sense, if they wanted to make a list of all people still alive who published in these fields. This year they sent me one for "Who's who in the world". Very suspicious, surely I did nothing to deserve listing in such a book.
Well the chances are you did more than a lot of the people mentioned in it.
Must have harvested my name from an article in Woman's Day Magazine about how I went from being an Academy trained musician to graduating as an RN at age 53. Noteworthy but when I went to the local library to check out the authenticity of the publication the response at the reference desk was, "Oh, we don't carry that in this library anymore. It's become...well...sort of a joke. They will have it at the main branch." That solidified my doubts about putting up the requested $367.00 for the leather-bound edition with my name engraved FREE, before it hits the stands in Nov. at twice the price!
If you check out the books, it seems that librarians form a large portion of the people in them. I guess their business model is to flatter enough librarians so that every library will buy one.
It's certainly not a scam (at least not in the usual sense). Marquis books have been published for over 100 years and (at least initially) they were very prestigious and selective. Nowadays, they are very weakly selective, inviting virtually anyone who has done anything noteworthy (or is in their database for some reason).
You are quite right that their business model is to flatter librarians, who will be among the first invited (and one of the first to buy the books). Also, selling books, certificates, cups or whatever vanity product you can think of to listees is definitely fair game.
Still, I would not judge them too harshly. It is conceivable that the books do have some biographical value, it is not for nothing that most large libraries stock them. Before the advent of the Internet, people did put their CVs online on the homepage (well, most people still don't, in most fields outside research). I can imagine it is difficult to get any information about who is who then. The only thing is that being listed doesn't mean you actually achieved anything noteworthy.
Dear Dr. Joe:
I admit I am a bit vexed about the legitimacy, or lack of the same, regarding Who’s Who publications, BUT I am happy to report that the Marquis publications do seem to find their way into large-scale libraries, at least on the west side of the Atlantic. So far as I can discern, they are the only seeming “vanity” products that are so recognized. As far as I am concerned, appearing in both the America and World editions it has not harmed me in any way, except of course in the PURSE because I wanted copies of the tomes (I think I am on p. 2501 of the World edition), and there are times when that actually seems to open a door now and then, if only for social or similarly frivolous reasons.
John S. Sultzbaugh
sltzbgh@yahoo.com
Yep, got one myself. Today.
The giveaway is the "biographical form". If they were a genuine outfit, they would only be approaching you if they ALREADY HAD THAT INFORMATION.
Phishing, or phishing enablers.
Hi Joe, adding to the list I would like to report that the e-mail have found ist way to Sweden aswell. I'm a PhD candidate at Lund University, quite unknown but with one published article in an US journal a couple of years ago. Seems a bit time consuming to hand pick candidates for the "phishing", I would guess they go for University adress lists or lists of participants from conferenses or so. Flattering, but a bit premature, to be called "Dear Dr Wengelin".
Post a Comment
<< Home